Our critique of
Fox News
· 2 min read
Politics
Text size

Fox Checked the Trucks. Then Put Islam on Trial.

Ohio truckingIslamic Center of MainevilleSafety versus collective blameOwner: Murdoch family
👁Decoded

Fox's latest Ohio trucking report seems to require a mechanic and a theologian. Checking the brakes? Sensible. Checking whether a whole religion belongs in the neighborhood? That's quite an extra service.

The November 15 article reports company safety violations, a police crackdown and residents' complaints about the Uzbek community. Then comes a resident saying: "Christian values are not compatible with Islamic values". Apparently, we've reached the religious section of the vehicle inspection.

Fox didn't invent that statement. A resident said it, and reporting hostility at a public meeting can be news. But in our view, putting it into a long list of community grievances without examining that sweeping claim lets a truck-safety story become a case against Muslim neighbors.

There is serious reporting here. Unsafe vehicles, licensing failures and allegations against particular operators deserve scrutiny. So do questions about company money. None of that requires treating a place of worship as evidence that its neighbors don't belong. A defective brake hose doesn't explain anybody's faith.

On October 25, Fox reported that the prosecutor had no information mosque fundraising broke the law. That doesn't clear every company or settle every question. It does show why company records and suspicions about a congregation need to stay separate.

To its credit, the new article includes the Uzbek association's offer to listen and work with residents. So this isn't a complaint that Fox gave the community no voice. It's about the huge burden placed on that voice: answering not just specific complaints, but suspicion of a whole community.

Local families deserve safe roads. Muslim families are local families too. They don't become less entitled to fair treatment because somebody with the same birthplace or religion faces an allegation. Investigate the person, the company and the evidence. Leave the collective character trial out of it.

In our view, Fox's reporting would be stronger if it kept that line clear. Find the dangerous trucks. Hold the responsible operators accountable. The inspection doesn't need a question about where everybody prays.

“A defective brake hose doesn't explain anybody's faith.”