Our critique of
AP
Β· 3 min read
Weird
Text size

The Reflecting Pool's Real Repeat Offender Is a $14.6 Million Liner.

AP: "Former Olympic canoe racer pleads not guilty in Reflecting Pool damage case"David Hearn, 67, three-time Olympian, faces up to 10 years in prison over ~2 sq ft of linerNo-bid contract to Atlantic Industrial Coatings ballooned from $13.1M to $14.6M; billed a 20% profit margin vs. the standard 6-12%Same contractor previously worked on Trump's golf club pool in Sterling, VirginiaOwner: nonprofit cooperative (member news orgs)
πŸ‘Decoded

David Hearn is 67. He canoed in three Olympics. On Thursday he stood in D.C. Superior Court and pleaded not guilty to a felony for allegedly pulling loose about two square feet of pool liner. Two square feet. That's a bath mat.

AP's headline: "Former Olympic canoe racer pleads not guilty in Reflecting Pool damage case." Very calm. Very court-reporter-doing-their-taxes energy. You'd never guess the courtroom was packed to the walls with supporters chanting his name.

Here's the real repeat offender in this story, and it isn't a 67-year-old with a paddle β€” it's the liner itself. It's part of a $14.6 million no-bid contract, handed to a Virginia company that, Trump himself has said, also did the pool at his golf club. That company billed a 20% profit margin on the job. Industry standard is 6 to 12%. The liner has failed often enough that the whole pool is being drained AGAIN to fix it. Again.

So: the guy who touched two square feet of failing plastic is facing up to 10 years. The contractor whose plastic keeps failing is facing a second paycheck. If this were a restaurant, it's like arresting a customer for poking a moldy breadstick while the bakery that made it gets the catering contract for next year's gala too.

Hearn says he touched a loose chunk and let go the second a park worker told him to. Prosecutors say "forcefully and violently." Whichever version you believe, nobody disputes the liner was already peeling before he got near it. It came that way.

AP didn't get anything wrong. It just covered a $16 million accountability story as a two-square-foot vandalism story.

β€œHe's charged with damaging a liner that was already falling apart on its own. The liner's contractor got a second contract instead.”