Our critique of
Al Jazeera
Β· 3 min read
Politics
Text size

Al Jazeera Wrote Its Founder's Obituary. One Word Didn't Make the Cut.

AJ: 'architect of modern Qatar'Wire obits: 'modernizer who seized power''Assumed power' vs a 1995 palace coupAl Jazeera was founded by his decree in 1996Owner: Government of Qatar
πŸ‘Decoded

Sheikh Hamad bin Khalifa Al Thani, Qatar's Father Emir, died Sunday morning at 74; funeral prayers were held in Doha the same evening. Every newsroom on earth filed an obituary. One of those newsrooms exists because he signed a decree in 1996. Let's read that one closely.

Al Jazeera's obituary: "Sheikh Hamad bin Khalifa Al Thani, the architect of modern Qatar." Inside, the network he created gets a proud cameo β€” "the launch of the Al Jazeera news channel in 1996" β€” written in the third person, like a museum caption. No "that's us." No disclosure line. The house wrote the obituary of the man who built the house and listed itself among his renovations.

Now the verb. Al Jazeera's account of how his reign began: he "assumed power as emir on June 27, 1995." Assumed β€” the way you assume a chair someone left empty. What actually happened, per the rest of the world's obituary desks: he deposed his own father in a bloodless palace coup while the old man was out of the country.

Compare the wire headline that ran on NBC News, among others: "Former Qatar ruler Sheikh Hamad, a modernizer who seized power, has died." Seized β€” right there in the headline. Same man, same June morning in 1995, one verb of distance. "Assumed" is doing very quiet, very loyal work.

The 2013 half of the story, Al Jazeera tells straight β€” and generously. His handover to his son was a "peaceful, voluntary transfer of leadership," one that was "rare in the region." Which is true! It genuinely was rare. It's just easier to celebrate how gracefully a man left the stage once you've repainted the door he came in through.

About the man himself, the record is genuinely enormous β€” gas wealth turned into global clout, votes for women, a World Cup, and a satellite channel that drove every other government in the region up the wall. There are real reasons the obituaries are long today, and a funeral is no venue for a prosecution.

But there's a difference between softening a life and rewriting its first chapter. Every desk sands a corner on the day of a death; only one desk had its founding document signed by the deceased. When that's the hand holding the pen, "architect of modern Qatar" isn't a headline. It's a thank-you card.

β€œThe wires wrote that he seized power. The network he founded wrote that he assumed it.”