Our critique of
The Wall Street Journal
· 3 min read
Politics
Text size

America Declared War on a Court. The Announcement Ran Where Nobody Asks Questions.

"brick by brick, if necessary""so-called international law"Op-ed as podiumEU: "simply not acceptable"Owner: News Corp (Murdoch family)
👁Decoded

On Monday the State Department announced a "whole-of-government" campaign to dismantle the International Criminal Court — the tribunal in The Hague that tries war crimes when nobody else will. That's the news. The interesting part is where the news was allowed to happen.

Not at a podium. Not in a press room with reporters and their annoying hands in the air. Secretary of State Marco Rubio launched the campaign with a produced video and an op-ed in The Wall Street Journal, promising America will dismantle the ICC "brick by brick, if necessary."

Think about what each format comes with. A press conference comes with follow-ups: Which allies have signed on? What happens to countries that stay in the court? Who investigates war crimes once it's rubble? An op-ed page comes with a byline photo and total, blessed silence.

The video, meanwhile, says the ICC and its friends are "waging a war against our country, not with bullets or missiles, but with statutes, compacts and the force of so-called international law." You can write "so-called international law" in an op-ed. At a podium, someone gets to ask which part, exactly, is so-called.

The rest of the press then covered the op-ed as the event. CNN: "Rubio vows to 'dismantle' International Criminal Court." Al Jazeera: "Trump administration vows to 'disable' International Criminal Court." Scare quotes working double shifts, because the only source text available was the government's own prose.

Euronews at least got the story to day two: "EU says threats against ICC 'unacceptable' as US launches campaign to 'dismantle' court" — quoting the EU spokesperson that attacks or threats against the court's officials "are simply not acceptable." That's what coverage is supposed to do: find someone who gets to answer back.

An op-ed is opinion, by definition, and opinion pages publish powerful people every day. But when the author is the Secretary of State and the content is a live policy campaign against a court, the Journal's opinion page isn't hosting a viewpoint. It's distributing a press release with nicer typography — and the one thing a press release never has to survive is a question.

“A podium comes with questions. An op-ed page comes with a byline photo and silence.”