AP Buried Its Best Line Under the Most Boring Verb in English
AP headline verb: 'faces'AP's own subhead: 'Blanche defends Trump's audit immunity deal'$1.8B anti-weaponization fund: 'not moving forward'Audit immunity 'remains on track'Owner: nonprofit cooperative (member news orgs)
πDecoded
The biggest Justice Department confirmation hearing of the year, and AP's headline went with this: "The Latest: Todd Blanche faces US Senate for DOJ confirmation hearing."
*
Faces. He faced it. Todd Blanche successfully sat in a chair and pointed his head toward some senators. Bold stuff. Somebody get this man a certificate for attendance.
*
The frustrating part is that AP had the real story the whole time. It's sitting in AP's own copy, about a third of the way down, under a section header AP wrote itself: "Blanche defends Trump's audit immunity deal." Defends! The verb was in the building! It was on the same page! It just wasn't allowed near the top.
*
Quick background, because the deal matters: Trump and his two oldest sons sued the IRS over the leak of his tax returns. The settlement that ended the suit created a $1.8 billion "anti-weaponization" fund to pay people who said the government had been weaponized against them. That fund is now toast. Blanche told the committee, "There's no commissioners. It's not moving forward."
*
But the settlement had a second half β the half that shields the president and his family from IRS audits on past returns. That one didn't die. In AP's own words: "Blanche has previously said the audit immunity remains on track."
*
So one half of the deal is a corpse and the other half is a bodyguard, and guess which half everybody's talking about. The dead fund is the safe outrage β it's gone, you can yell at it for free. The audit immunity is the part still clocking in every morning.
*
NPR at least raised an eyebrow. Its takeaway was titled "The anti-weaponization fund is dead. Kind of?" That question mark is doing more reporting than AP's entire headline verb.
*
And the hearing handed everyone a gift. Republican Sen. John Kennedy, lobbing a friendly one, asked Blanche whether he and Trump were friends. Blanche answered, "I'm his lawyer" β then caught it and downgraded to "was his lawyer." Asked about friendship, the acting attorney general reached for his job description, in the present tense, and had to reverse mid-sentence.
*
Other outlets found a verb with a pulse. The Washington Post: "Blanche insists he's not Trump's 'yes man' as attorney general vote looms." Bloomberg called it a "fiery hearing." CNN said he was "grilled." Fox News went with "faces" too, so AP has company in the furniture aisle.
*
AP's plain-wire style is a feature, not a bug β half the news you read is built on it, and the flat version is usually the honest one. But "faces" isn't flat. "Faces" describes where a man's head was pointed. AP typed the word "defends" one scroll down, then filed it behind the one verb guaranteed to make you keep scrolling.
βAP typed βdefendsβ one scroll down, then led with where the man's head was pointed.β
Comments (4)
TallaghtTed
somebody get this man a certificate lol. the audit immunity deal deserves its own piece tbh
20m ago
ZeynepReads
The buried subhead being sharper than the headline is such a specific wire-desk pathology. The good sentence exists! Promote it!
1h ago
media101prof
The 'certificate for attendance' line got me. But to be fair to wire desks, 'faces' is the standard live-blog hedge β the crime here is that 'defends audit immunity deal' was already written in AP's own copy. They out-reported their own headline.
1h ago
deadline_dan
'faces' is the wire service getting credit for covering the thing without ever saying the thing