Our critique of
France 24
· 3 min read
Politics
Text size

Morocco Spied on French Ministers. France 24's Headline Investigated France.

F24: 'France explored Pegasus spyware deal'Guardian: 'Moroccan intelligence insider reveals'F24 standfirst ends: 'Morocco has denied'PM Lecornu was in Rabat that same dayOwner: France Médias Monde (French state)
👁Decoded

The Forbidden Stories consortium dropped fresh Pegasus revelations today: a Moroccan intelligence insider and new forensics showing Rabat ran the Israeli spyware against journalists, human rights defenders, Spanish officials — and French ministers, reportedly including Sébastien Lecornu, France's current prime minister. The timing was exquisite. Lecornu spent this very day in Rabat, warming up Franco-Moroccan relations.

Here's the Guardian, a consortium veteran, headlining the material: "Moroccan intelligence insider reveals widespread use of Pegasus hacking software." Subject: the insider. Verb: reveals. Object: Morocco's hacking. You know — the news.

Now France 24, owned by the same French state whose prime minister was mid-handshake: "France explored Pegasus spyware deal despite Morocco espionage claims." Read that twice. The active subject is France, and its offense is window-shopping in 2019 for spyware it never bought. Morocco's actual espionage — the reason any of this is a story — has been demoted to a subordinate clause wearing an "allegedly."

The standfirst keeps the bubble wrap coming: "according to media investigations," "the report claims," and then the closer — "Morocco has denied the spying allegations." Forensic traces and an insider from the agency itself get "claims." The denial gets the last word.

Even France 24's straighter news piece went with "Rabat faces allegations of spying on Paris." Faces allegations — the diplomatic passive where an intelligence operation becomes something that politely happens to its perpetrator.

And here's the clever part: "France once considered buying Pegasus" reads as brave self-criticism. State broadcaster, dinging its own government! Except of the two embarrassments on offer today, that's by far the safer one — it's seven years old, it ends with Macron saying no, and it doesn't point at the palace whose hand the prime minister was shaking that afternoon.

France 24's own press-review show accidentally wrote the honest headline: "New Pegasus spyware revelations as French PM visits Morocco." That's the story. It just ran as a summary of what other people's newspapers were printing.

When a state broadcaster must choose between embarrassing its government a little and embarrassing its government's host a lot, "a little" wins every time — and gets dressed up as fearlessness on the way out.

“Of the two embarrassments on offer, France 24 picked the one that doesn't point at the host.”