Our critique of
Fox News
Β· 2 min read
Politics
Text size

Trump Declared. The Data Just 'Claimed.'

'reports emerged claiming''virtually all' ATACMS used'treasonous' leakers, day twoVerb asymmetryOwner: Murdoch family
πŸ‘Decoded

Here's a fun grammar exercise. In Fox's Thursday story on the munitions row, President Trump "declared" that the U.S. has a "massive" stockpile, and he "vows" that leakers are being hunted down. The Reuters reporting he was responding to β€” the one citing people familiar with internal U.S. military data β€” arrived in the very same lede as "reports emerged claiming." The dek softens it further: reports "suggesting" a weapons shortage.

Quick background, one sentence, because that's all it needs: Reuters reported Tuesday that the Army has used "virtually all" of its ATACMS and Precision Strike Missiles in five months of war with Iran, and Trump responded by promising "long term jail sentences" for whoever told them.

Now look at who gets which verb. The man asserting something with zero documents attached gets "declared" β€” a verb with shoulders. The reporting built on internal military data gets "claiming" and "suggesting" β€” verbs you use for your mate who swears he saw a UFO. Fox never disputes a single number in the piece. It doesn't have to. The verbs do the work the numbers couldn't.

And we have to talk about the headline, because we literally just covered this. On Wednesday, Trump's post called the leaked STATEMENTS treasonous, and Fox's headline quietly moved the adjective onto the people β€” "treasonous leakers." We flagged it. Thursday's headline: Trump "vows 'treasonous' leakers being hunted down." Same transplant, second day running. Once is a slip. Twice, on consecutive days, on the same story? That's a style guide.

Meanwhile the actual subject of the story β€” the missiles β€” never makes it into Fox's headline at all. The headline has Trump, a stockpile adjective, and a manhunt. What it doesn't have is the thing that started all this: two weapons systems at rock bottom, per the internal data of Trump's own Pentagon.

For contrast: CNN ran "Trump grows angry over reports on depleted munitions." You can quibble with the palace-intrigue framing β€” anger as the story β€” but note what CNN's headline treats as solid: the reports. In Foxland the reports "claim." In CNN-land the reports simply exist and the president is mad at them. Same day, same facts, two different realities, and only one of them needed scare-quote verbs to hold together.

One more detail, free of charge: in his own post, Trump wrote that the U.S. has massive amounts of "munitions" β€” with munitions in quotation marks. Even the stockpile's owner air-quoted it. The leakers couldn't have done it better themselves.

β€œThe man with zero documents got 'declared.' The internal military data got 'claiming.'”