NPR Found Voters Who Like Socialists and Filed It as an Absence of Hate
NPR: 'say they are not dismissing'Lede: 'might not be quick to reject'10 of 12 swing voters open to socialistsCNN: 'shook the progressive left for a change'Owner: nonprofit/member stations
👁Decoded
NPR sat in on two focus groups of Nevada swing voters this week — real Biden-to-Trump switchers, the most fought-over humans in American politics — and found something genuinely striking: 10 of the 12 said a candidate calling themselves a socialist wouldn't bother them. One woman described socialists as people trying to make sure "everybody has rights and everybody has food, everybody has a house, everybody has a job." Another said they're "more about community" than corporate Democrats. That's the data. Now here's the headline NPR built for it: "These swing voters in Nevada say they are not dismissing socialist candidates."
*
Say they are not dismissing. Count the airbags. The finding is affection, or at least openness — and the sentence expresses it as a failure to reject. The lede goes one better: "Some swing voters might not be quick to reject socialist political candidates." Some. Might. Not be quick to. Reject. Four hedges stacked in front of the actual news like sandbags before a flood. Nobody at NPR has ever typed "voters say they are not dismissing capitalist candidates," because capitalism doesn't need a permission slip to be likable. The double negative is the tell: in the house grammar of American political journalism, socialism's default state is dismissed, and any other reading is a man-bites-dog event.
*
The moderator NPR quotes does the same dance: he was "struck by the receptivity," the voters "weren't willing to automatically dismiss it," they were "way more open to socialism than any swing voter otherwise would be." Fair enough — surprise is his honest reaction, and it's his job to have priors. But a newsroom's job is to notice when the reaction has become the story. Ten of twelve is not "not dismissing." Ten of twelve is a result.
*
Yesterday we graded this exact vocabulary. CNN's Wisconsin takeaways called Francesca Hong a "socialist" in every clause while her opponent walked around adjective-free, and Fox ran "Dem establishment scores win as Crowley defeats socialist Hong." NPR, we noted, was the control group — the only headline that just used two names and a verb. That praise stands. But today shows the assumption lives even in the label-free newsroom: NPR doesn't sneer at socialists; it's just permanently astonished that anyone else doesn't. CNN, same morning, went with "Inside the Wisconsin upset that shook the progressive left for a change" — for a change, a smirk you can hear from here.
*
Credit where it's earned, because this is otherwise the way you do it: NPR disclosed everything. "Focus groups are not scientifically significant like polls" is right there in the piece; the firms are named; the two dissenters get quoted, including the guy who finds it all "too extreme." After we spent a piece this week dismantling an NPR poll story that forgot its own margin of error, this is the version with its homework attached. The reporting is honest. The reflexes are the story.
*
And buried in the piece is the reason the reflexes matter: 10 of the 12 said they're more economically anxious than a year ago. A woman who pays for groceries on credit cards. A son who's worked the Vegas Strip for 22 years and can't make rent. The moderator calls their openness to socialism "any port in a storm." Notice what that framing does — it converts a political preference into a symptom. When comfortable people choose a candidate, it's called a decision. When struggling people do, it's called a storm.
*
The voters aren't confused about what they think. The headline is. Somewhere between Jasmine saying "I need to just get to know them completely" and the copy desk typing "not dismissing," a plain finding got dressed in negation — because the alternative was a sentence American political journalism still isn't sure it's allowed to write: swing voters kind of like these people.
“Ten of twelve is not 'not dismissing.' Ten of twelve is a result.”
Comments (4)
CorkCynic
not dismissing is doing olympic level work in that headline
6d ago
HowthHeadline
To be fair to NPR, at least they went to Nevada and asked actual switchers. The hedging is annoying but the shoe-leather is real.
6d ago
portobello_paul
everybody has food, house, job is the whole ballgame quote and its buried under hedges. good spot
6d ago
ZeynepReads
Following on from the Wisconsin piece — NPR cannot decide if socialists are radioactive or just mildly warm. Might not be quick to reject is a sentence wearing three life jackets.