'Depleted' Finally Made a Headline. Nobody Named Who Did the Depleting.
Todd Blanche gave his first speech as attorney general Thursday, in the Great Hall, five days after the Senate confirmed him 50-49 at four in the morning. We have reviewed every season of this show — the stall NBC headlined as "disagreements," the finale it headlined as "weeks of uncertainty," the $1.776 billion fund that never once cracked a headline. So Thursday's speech coverage got graded on exactly one question: does the headline admit there's damage in the room?
*
AP passed. "Blanche seeks to rally a depleted Justice Department workforce in first speech as attorney general." Two words doing honest labor. "Depleted" states the condition of the audience as fact — not an allegation, not a critics-say. And "seeks to" files the rally as attempted, not achieved; the wire is grading the speech as an effort, not transcribing it as a result. The body goes further: the "beleaguered agency," a confirmation fight that "exposed deep concerns," and the clause most desks would launder into mush — critics' alarm that Blanche "is still functioning as Trump's personal lawyer." That sentence, in an AP wire story, prints in hundreds of local papers that will never assign a DOJ reporter. That's what wire discipline is for.
*
Now CNN's headline: "Todd Blanche makes plea for unity at Justice Department." Look at what each desk chose to grade. AP looked at the room; CNN looked at the podium. "Makes plea" is a completed speech-act — plea delivered, mission transcribed. The state of the workforce, the thing AP put in the headline, waits inside CNN's body. To be fair, that body delivers: the speech "seemed to erase more than a year of upheaval," the pledge not to "engage in or stand for any sort of performative attacks" arrives with the note that this is precisely what "critics have accused the department of repeatedly doing," and Justice Connection's Stacey Young supplies the missing arithmetic — "hundreds of DOJ's career workforce have been fired because of their backgrounds, their perceived politics." All good. All downstairs.
*
Against this beat's headline record, AP printing "depleted" is almost radical. For a month the vocabulary was weather-forecast nouns — "disagreements," "uncertainty" — words that describe a fight the way "moisture" describes a flood. An adjective that concedes something actually happened to actual employees is progress.
*
Which is why the remaining nitpick matters. "Depleted" is agentless. Workforces don't deplete the way aquifers do; somebody depletes them. Young's statement names the mechanism — people fired "for fiercely pushing back in conference rooms throughout the country." The depleting was done by the leadership Blanche now fronts, including the stretch when he was deputy attorney general — which is to say, management. Neither headline seats that fact where readers sit. "Depleted" is a condition. Somewhere in the building is a verb with a name on it.
*
Still, grade on the curve this arc has earned. One desk transcribed the podium; one diagnosed the room; neither identified the treating physician as the cause of the injury. But only one admitted the injury exists above the fold, and after "disagreements" and "uncertainty," we will take the adjective. Next milestone: a headline containing both the damage and the doer. The wires can afford the word count.
“'Depleted' is a condition. Somewhere in the building is a verb with a name on it.”