Saturday night The Wall Street Journal filed a visit story: "Iran War Commander Visits the USS Abraham Lincoln." Admiral Brad Cooper toured the most talked-about ship in the Navy and told history where to file it β the deployment will be recorded as among "the most operationally intense and consequential of the modern era." That quote got the marquee. And the nine months of plumbing failures, food rationing and mental-health reports that made this ship famous in the first place? They ride along in the dek as "...whose stop comes amid reports of poor living conditions." Amid. Of course.
*
The Journal is developing a habit. On Thursday its carrier-swap headline was "U.S. Sending Fresh Aircraft Carrier to Middle East Amid Iran War Strain." Two Lincoln stories in seventy-two hours, and both times the entire human cost of a record deployment hangs off the least committal preposition in the English language. We wrote a whole piece on Wednesday about "amid" carrying an aircraft carrier on its back. The Journal appears to have read it as a style guide.
*
The same weekend, NPR ran the counter-headline: "Families of USS Lincoln crew say Trump should be 'ashamed' of conditions on board." Subject: the families. Verb: say. Object: shame, aimed at a named person. Inside, a grandmother, Karen Bramlett, who talks to her sailor grandson on Instagram about once a week and wouldn't let NPR print his name for fear of repercussions: "He's just depressed. With the conditions over there you really can't blame him." Enlisting was his dream. "Those dreams have been shattered." And the line NPR promoted to its headline: "Donald Trump needs to be ashamed of himself to let them suffer the way that they're doing... They're over there fighting for our country. And this is the thanks they get?"
*
Three quotes fought for the weekend's headlines. A president, asked Friday if the deployment had gone on too long: "No, not nearly long enough." A grandmother: "ashamed." An admiral: "history will record." Which one your outlet promoted tells you exactly who it thinks this story belongs to β the legacy, the ledger, or the people locked inside it.
*
And then there's the Navy's own dialect, printed in full by NPR. Acting Navy Secretary Hung Cao, in a statement: "Meal plans were adjusted when fresh resupply was unavailable, without a single meal being missed. Calls home were limited when the operational threat was too high." Meal plans were adjusted. Calls home were limited. By whom? The sentence declines to say. Earlier in the week the Navy's version at least had a subject β "Leadership prioritized mission-critical supplies." By the weekend even the leadership had dissolved into the passive voice, leaving hardship to occur on its own, like tides.
*
Credit where due, and it's mostly NPR's this week: it flagged that the sailors-overboard reports are ones it "has not been able to independently confirm" β a hedge finally standing in the right doorway β and it appended a correction for misspelling Cao's name. Once. One letter. On the record, unprompted. After the week we've had with corrections that name no one and clarify nothing, a newsroom fixing a single letter in public reads almost radical. Meanwhile Senator Gallego told NPR he wants a bipartisan visit to the ship so that senators can verify "the secretary of defense is not lying to us" β United States senators, reduced to the same sourcing as Grandma Bramlett: ask the sailors directly.
*
The Lincoln is finally turning for home, roughly five thousand people aboard, with a relief carrier en route. When it docks, someone will write the homecoming headline, and you should watch its subject slot like a hawk. If the sailors own the verb, the record deployment finally got a protagonist. If it's another "amid," the Journal's style guide won β and history, as the admiral says, will record it.
βThree quotes fought for the headlines: 'not long enough,' 'ashamed,' and 'history will record.'β