The First Blockade in History Whose Selling Point Is That It's Open
Fox: 'Hormuz Strait will remain open, we are reinstating blockade'Trump: 'reimbursed, at the rate of 20% on all cargo shipped'Al Jazeera: 'collect tolls' — Bloomberg: '20% Hormuz Charge'Announced on Fox & FriendsOwner: Murdoch family
👁Decoded
Monday morning, Trump announced that the US is reinstating its blockade of Iranian ships in the Strait of Hormuz, appointing itself "THE GUARDIAN OF THE HORMUZ STRAIT," and collecting 20% on cargo passing through for the trouble. One announcement. Four wildly different headlines — and the words each outlet picked tell you exactly where they were standing.
*
Al Jazeera: "Trump says US will become 'guardian' of Strait of Hormuz and collect tolls." Tolls. The word you use for a booth, a barrier and a man pointing at a bucket. Bloomberg went with "Trump to Restart Iran Blockade as US Plans 20% Hormuz Charge" — a charge, something that appears on an invoice and gets disputed by your accountant.
*
And then there's Fox's live blog: "Trump warns Iran: Hormuz Strait will remain open, we are reinstating blockade." Read it twice. The strait will remain open. Also: blockade. That's not a headline, that's a Zen koan with a carrier group.
*
The key word in Trump's own version is "reimbursed" — the US will be "reimbursed, at the rate of 20% on all cargo shipped" for "providing safety and security." Lovely choice. You get reimbursed for expenses somebody agreed you should make. Nobody in the strait ordered the security. That's a man putting a chair at the end of your street, declaring the street officially open, and taking 20% of your shopping on the way past — then calling your contribution a reimbursement.
*
To be fair to Fox, its main headline did print the number: "Trump says US will charge 20% fee for Strait of Hormuz passage." A fee. Fees are for gyms and late library books. Tolls are what you pay to pass. There's a third word, the one Iran's side reached for, but let's not get ahead of ourselves.
*
CNN, meanwhile, filed the whole day under "Ceasefire disintegrates as Trump says US will reinstate blockade of Iranian ships in Strait of Hormuz." Disintegrates — the ceasefire just dissolving on its own, like a tablet in water, in the same headline as the man announcing he's ending it. Give the verb a medal for diplomacy.
*
Here's the part that matters: Trump made the announcement on Fox & Friends. Fox wasn't covering the toll booth — Fox was the ribbon-cutting venue. And the venue's takeaway headline was that the strait "will remain open." Al Jazeera, watching from the region that pays the 20%, headlined the part where you pay. Same booth. One outlet showed you the barrier going up; the other showed you the OPEN sign hanging on it.
“It's only a blockade in the sense that you pay a stranger 20% not to be blockaded.”
Comments (3)
RathminesReader
Read this on the bus and laughed at the pay-a-stranger-not-to-be-blockaded line. Properly dark underneath it though.
26m ago
jornolurker
the 20% toll is the detail of the week. that's not a blockade that's a bouncer with a card machine
1h ago
media101prof
A blockade whose selling point is that it's open is doing the same job as 'targeted strikes' — the adjective exists to pre-answer the objection. The toll detail is the whole story.